People talk
Our Guestbook
“ One of the most delicious italian/ Chicago style pizzas in waco thus far. Highly recommend ”
“ Our fav place to come relax after a hard night TJ always knows our orders and is our favorite part of coming by. It’s great to know we will get great service every time we come by. Sunset beach is a 10/10 ”
“ Great pizza and burgers. Great COLD beer selections specially if you want beer to try that is out of the norm. Ask for a taste of beer before you buy! Tried the peach wheat tonight. Always a great experience and i love to come when they do trivia night! ”
“ Pizza and calzone were amazing! Great service from the bartender.. ”
“ First time here. There was no hostess at the front to greet customers. There was, however, a sign that read "go to the bar, see the bartender for seating." I ordered two Calzones. They were made soooooo good. The Marinera dipping sauce was on point. The Calzones were filled with alot of meats, vegetables and cheese. The dough was baked to perfection. What I believed were very thick edges of JUST DOUGH on the Calzones, turned out to be that the edges were also stuffed with cheese and meat. I drank two cocktails. Great bartender. Great customer service. The food was hot. Cheese all melted and just great Calzones. Highly recommend. ”
“ My husband and I stopped in last week for dinner. Mallory was our server and gave wonderful service. TJ was the bartender and he really is fantastic. Very accommodating. Love that guy! We ordered the Nashville Hot Wings. They were not very hot. Mallory let us know the regular hot wings have a better kick.Will try those next time. Our pizza was the hand tossed ale crust and we did half and half on the toppings. We loved it. Add in all the taps and what’s not to love? This is our second trip here and it’s on our favorites list now. Great job guys. We hope the Detroit style makes a comeback one day. ”
“ We came here for lunch on June 5th. The food and service was very good. Not your standard pizza place. This pizza was very flavorful, including the pizza sauce, which is quite often bland at other pizza shops. ”
“ When I dined here, it was late in the evening and the place looked dead. I was wary about going inside as I could not see a sign from my vantage point. I did go in, and I'm so glad that I did! Upon entering a young man greeted me. He ended up being the bar tender. Between cleaning for closing and serving his other patrons, he kept a vigilant eye on my dining cues. Brought a box just as I was finishing. He even saw my card and got me the card. He wasn't rushing me (they still had one hour before closing.) The food! From bite one, this picky pizza princess was engulfed in an experience that will have me returning to explore more of menu. They even passed the vibe check in more than one way! If you're considering popping in, stop waiting and get over there. 10/10!! Will advise with updates and other menu items!! ”
Menu
PARTY PACK FOR 4
US$29.99BUFFALO CHICKEN ROLL PLATTER
US$50.00GARDEN SALAD PLATTER
US$25.00CAESAR SALAD PLATTER
US$25.00ROASTED CHICKEN & APPLE WALNUT PLATTER
US$65.00
About
Old Chicago Pizza Taproom
Welcome to the vibrant world of Old Chicago Pizza Taproom, a true gem nestled in Waco, Texas, at 4641 S Jack Kultgen Expy. This lively establishment has become a go-to spot for pizza enthusiasts and casual diners alike, offering a warm atmosphere complemented by a menu that celebrates the art of pizza-making and the joy of sharing a meal with friends and family.
At Old Chicago Pizza Taproom, the star of the show is undoubtedly the pizza. With a nod to classic recipes and innovative creations, there’s a pie for every palate. The signature dishes are crafted with high-quality ingredients and a passion for flavor. One customer's experience highlights this perfectly: “Not your standard pizza place. This pizza was very flavorful, including the pizza sauce.” Indeed, each bite is a reminder of why pizza has captured the hearts of many.
But the menu doesn’t stop at pizza. Guests can indulge in mouthwatering starters such as the Cheesy Dippin' Strips, which are thick pizza crust strips baked to perfection and served with signature red sauce, or the Sicilian Pepperoni Rolls, a delightful twist on a classic, filled with pepperoni, cheese, and green onions. As one satisfied diner shares, “The Calzones were made soooooo good,” illustrating the attention to detail that the kitchen brings to the table.
For those who appreciate variety, the Keg of Wings is a must-try, featuring double the wings and sauce for those with hearty appetites. Whether you prefer bone-in or boneless, the wings here are all about maximizing flavor, making them a perfect companion to the extensive selection of craft beers on tap. Many patrons are particularly impressed by the unique beer options, stating, “Great COLD beer selections,” and noting the opportunity to try before you buy.
Old Chicago Pizza Taproom also knows the importance of a warm and welcoming staff. Reviews consistently praise the attentive service, with one guest mentioning, “TJ always knows our orders and is our favorite part of coming by.” It’s clear that the friendly atmosphere, combined with great food and drink, creates a memorable dining experience.
If you're planning a night out with friends, the Party Packs provide an excellent value, while trivia nights add a fun twist to your dining experience. Whether you're a local or just passing through, I encourage you to pop in and savor the excitement that each dish brings.
In conclusion, Old Chicago Pizza Taproom in Waco stands out not just for its incredible food but for its dedication to customer satisfaction and creating a comforting dining experience. So gather your friends, make your way to this must-visit spot, and indulge in a slice (or two!) of their flavorful offerings. Your taste buds will thank you!
Book a table